
Review of American factory: The cultural clash and labor tensions between Chinese management and American workers in a glass making factory.
12/17/24
The documentary American Factory centers on the cultural clash between Chinese
management and American workers in the U.S.-based Chinese company, Fuyao. Directed by Steven Bognar and Julia Reichert, who were interested in exploring the future of Chinese laborin the United States, it was produced on January 25, 2019.
The film premiered at the SundanceFilm Festival and was the first backed by Barack and Michelle Obama’s newly formed production company, Higher Ground Productions. Bognar and Reichert's film sheds light on the cultural clashes and labor differences within Fuyao, a foreign glass-making company located in Dayton, Ohio. The documentary delves into the tensions in the Chinese company, which is owned by Cao Dewang and managed by Jeff Daochuan Liu. Previously owned by General Motors, the factory was shut down, leaving hundreds unemployed, until the Chinese company revived it. This revival brought American workers together with Chinese management, setting the stage for an exploration of cultural dynamics.
​
​
​​
​
​
​
​

"This is political without being self-servingly didactic"
The tense culture clash in American Factory revealed the chasm in management and
employee workload expectations. A 2019 New York Times review by Monohla stated: “This is political without being self-servingly didactic or strident, connecting the sociopolitical dots intelligently”. The documentary sets the stage for understanding complexities in the globalized world. For Fuyao, the glass-making company, the most important concern was not how much they earned, but how Americans viewed Chinese immigrants and China as a major competitor in U.S. manufacturing. A major labor difference was evident, showing that this American-based company was successful largely because of the significant number of Chinese immigrants
willing to work long hours, while American workers worked fewer days and received higher pay.
The cultural clash surfaced when American workers protested the emphasis on quantity over quality, believing that Chinese immigrants were being asked to do too much for too little. One example is when a female Chinese worker was fired for taking a day off while severely sick. She said, “I am tired, but I have no choice. Safety does not pay the bills.” This highlighted how the workplace conditions were unfavorable and contributed to her illness. As an immigrant, she had no choice but to work undocumented, and Fuyao was the only company willing to offer her a job. The vice president of Fuyao Glass remarked, "America is a place to let your personality run
free" (1:14 minute mark). He argued that there is a cultural trait in the U.S. that makes its citizens overconfident. For many foreigners entering the United States, there is a level of rigidity they are accustomed to, and in a shared work environment, these differing cultural ideas and operationalmethods inevitably clash.
" I am tired but
i have no choice"

After witnessing this clash of cultures, it is time to reflect on the future of workforces. From this documentary, we see stark reasons why traditional forms of manufacturing might cease to exist in the United States or most Western countries due to excessive reliance on human labor.
We also observe how China places a significant burden on its labor force without appropriately rewarding the workers. We, the viewers, get to experience this culture clash and labor difference because we are captivated by a realistic and political realm that The New York Times discusses, which brings to light the immigration struggle. This documentary was acquired by Barack and Michelle Obama and produced by Steven Bognar andJulia Reichert in 2019.

"I have taken the peace of the people away "
​
The American workers are very displeased and express this by advocating for better working conditions, suggesting ways to make money while still being fair to employees. This is why they introduced the UAW (United Auto Workers Union), but the company attempts to eliminate the activists by firing them. We also hear from the chairman of the company, who wonders if he has taken peace away and destroyed the environment by building so many factories. Labor is not restricted to just humans; we also have robots entering the workforce, resulting in a shortage of job availability.
The American workers, who once worked for the General Motors plant that was previously located on the land now owned by Fuyao, had a strong sense of fairness and practice. They placed great value on job security and general principles recognized across the United States, while the Chinese had an entirely different principle focused on productivity. They approached this by requiring immigrant Chinese workers to work longer hours and produce faster.
​
The American workers wanted a balance between their work and personal lives, but the documentary provides a glimpse into how Chinese manufacturing companies operate, which is markedly different from American practices. The American representatives were perplexed when they witnessed the nature of workplaces in China. American Factory may not ultimately be a happy story for everyone, but it is a testament to the importance of the labor movement in this country and how it remains as relevant as ever, even as the face of industry changes irrevocably.
​
​

This is a must-see documentary on Netflix if you are interested in understanding how the workforce of foreign companies differs from the standard norms in American workplaces.
​
​

WORK CITED
Bradshaw, Peter. “American Factory: A Sobering Documentary by the Obamas.” The Guardian,
August 15, 2019.
https://www.theguardian.com/film/2019/aug/15/american-factory-review-a-sobering-
documentary-by-the-obamas.
Dargis, Manohla. “American Factory.” The New Global Haves and Have-Nots. The New York
Times, August 20, 2019.
https://www.nytimes.com/2019/08/20/movies/american-factory-review.html.
Powers, John. “American Factories: Work Cultures Clash When a Chinese Company Reopens an
American Factory.” NPR, September 10, 2019.
https://www.npr.org/2019/08/23/753109643/work-cultures-clash-when-a-chinese-
company-reopens-an-american-factory.
Smith, John. “The Impact of Globalization in American Manufacturing.” Global Discourse, vol.
34, 2020.
https://globaldiscourse.wordpress.com/wp-content/uploads/2011/05/john-smith.pdf.
White, Douglas Gerald. “Community, Nationalism, and Soccer in America’s Heartland: Chapter
2 Key Findings.” ProQuest, approved November 2010 by the Graduate Supervisory
Committee, Arizona State University, December 2010.
https://www.proquest.com/docview/820531320/A37B935FC6E34537PQ/26?accountid=
7398&sourcetype=Dissertations%20&%20Theses57.